Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (2024)

16 Comments

Organic Potting Mix and Organic Raised Bed Soil are both beneficial for providing essential natural nutrients and minerals for enclosed planting areas. Potting Mix is formulated to feed the soil for plants growing in indoor and outdoor containers, while Raised Bed Soil with its slightly larger particle size, has versatile uses for both larger containers and raised bed gardening. Check out the various attributes and differences between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil.

What is the Best Soil to Use in Pots?

In this video Bridget Ayers, a backyard gardener in Southern California – Zone 10b, shows us how she layers different organic soils, fertilizers, and amendments as part of her container garden planning process to start her seeds. Whether your garden is big or small, make the most of your space with these tips and watch the full Best Soil for Container Gardening video on the Kellogg Garden Youtube Channel.

Difference Bettween Garden Soil vs Potting Soil

Potting mix is meant to stand alone, as opposed to being mixed in with existing soils. It is a self-contained product designed to provide potted plants with everything they need to grow and thrive. Garden soil is meant to be spread around. Mix garden soil in with your native dirt to improve it.

What to Plant in Raised Garden Bed?

Moisture-loving plants that do well in raised garden beds includecardinal flowers, sedges, and monkshood. In a dry spot, try Russian sage, prairie plants (coreopsis, false indigo, big bluestem), Mediterranean herbs (rosemary, lavender), or succulents (including sedums and echeverias).

Potting Mix Attributes

When you plant in a container or pot, the soil environment is crucial to the plant’s ability to thrive. Potting Mix provides everything that a plant needs to grow in this isolated environment – moisture retention and nutrients.

Potting Mix Soil Composition and pH

Potting Mix contains the perfect texture of soil to maintain plant life in a pot or container. Its soil is well-balanced for proper moisture retention and drainage, which helps with effective air penetration through the plant root mass. Potting Mixes also provides plants with a balanced pH level to ensure plants thrive throughout the growing season.

Nutrients in Potting Mix

Organic Potting Mixes give your potted plants the nutrients it needs to grow, providing both short term and long term nutrient breakdown that continue to feed your plants for weeks at a time.

**Product not available in AZ, CA, HI, NV, UT.For a comparable product in these statesclick here.

How to Use Potting Mix

  1. Cover the base of the pot or container with potting mix and press down firmly.
  2. Following directions on the bag, mix in the correct amount of organic granular fertilizer
  3. Loosen up the soil around plant roots with your fingers and place the top of the root ball approximately two inches from the rim of the container.
  4. Fill the remainder of the pot or container with potting mix and press down firmly to secure the plant.
  5. Water in well, adding a liquid fertilizer every 2-3 weeks.

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (2)

Attributes of Raised Bed Soil

Raised Bed Soil provides the quintessential soil recipe for raised bed gardening and has significant benefits to gardeners and the plants that they grow. Like potting mixes, Raised Bed Garden Soil is cultivated to be used on its own in a raised bed that sits on the soil or is wholly enclosed in a container. Its use provides the perfect opportunity to establish the most favorable environment for your plants. It can be used for both raised beds and large container gardens.

Raised Bed Soil Nutrients

Raised Bed Soil is the optimal choice for filling your raised garden beds, as it is bolstered with a hardy amount of organic nutrients such as poultry meal, kelp meal and worm castings that will help feed the soil your plants will grow in. Don’t get complacent though!

All organic gardens, including raised bed gardens, require additional organic fertilizer through the growing season. Edibles, many of which are grown in raised beds, are heavy feeders and need nutrient replenishment with an organic granular fertilizer every 5-6 weeks. And like potting mixes, supplementing with an organic liquid fertilizer like every 2-3 weeks will yield the best results.

What is the pH of Raised Bed Soil?

A common question is, what is the pH of Raised Bed Soil? Raised Bed Soil takes the guesswork out of determining the soil quality because it is already pH balanced to be between 5.8 and 7.5, which is optimal for growing vegetables in a raised bed garden or flowers.

Well-Draining Raised Bed Soil

Raised Bed Soil is like a balance between garden soil and potting mix. It has the exceptional drainage necessary for container and raised bed gardening and it assists gardeners in maintaining loose soil which provides adequate airflow for necessary oxygen and nutrient delivery to root systems.

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (3)

Is Raised Bed Soil Ready to Use?

Many ask, is raised bed soil ready to use? Since it is already formulated to be used right out of the bag, gardeners don’t have to contend with adding soil amendments to get a raised garden started. However, many gardeners use Raised Bed Soil as the base mix and add their own compost and other soil amendments to create their own “recipe!” That’s part of the fun with gardening!

Adding Raised Bed Soil to Existing Soil

Ever wonder why the soil in your raised bed seems to “shrink” each season? Beneficial soil microbes consume the soil through the year which helps create plant-available nutrients your plants need to thrive. At the start of each season, spread a layer of Raised Bed Soil within 3-4 inches of the top of your raised bed. Then, mix it with the existing soil to a depth of four to six inches. Now is a good time to mix in that organic granular fertilizer!

Using Raised Bed Soil in Containers and Raised Beds

When using raised bed soil in containers and raised beds simply fill the raised bed or container with Raised Bed Soil to 3-4 inches below the top.

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (4)

Using Raised Bed Soil in Containers

  1. Cover the base of the pot or container with Raised Bed Soil and press down firmly.
  2. Following directions on the package, add an organic granular fertilizer.
  3. Loosen up the plant roots with your fingers and place the top of the root ball approximately two- inches from the rim of the container.
  4. Fill the remainder of the pot or container with Raised Bed Soil and press down firmly to secure the plant.
  5. Water in well, adding a liquid fertilizer every 2-3 weeks.

Using Raised Bed Soil in Raised Beds

  1. Add the Raised Bed Soil to the raised bed.
  2. Following directions on the package, add an organic granular fertilizer to each hole where you are going to place a plant.
  3. Loosen up the plant roots and place the plant into the soil mix so that the root ball is slightly above ground level.
  4. Water in well, adding a liquid fertilizer every 2-3 weeks.

Get all the soil you need from Kellogg Organic Soil, find a store near you today!

Share The Garden Love

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (5)

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (6)

16 Comments

Leave a Reply
  1. Thank you so much for all the great information. I greatly appreciate it.

    Reply

    • We’re happy to hear you’re enjoying our posts!

      Reply

  2. Great information. Thank you.

    Reply

  3. U guys are amazing ❤ thank u for shering ❤️

    Reply

  4. Just bought a new electric tiller and 100 cu. ft. of Kellogg raised bed soil at Home Depot. Reworked two tiered beds after removing wasps loving shrubs.Added a third tier at bottom. Also built a big box further out in yard. And built two strawberry pyramids and a box for watermelons and cantaloupe. Used most all the raised bed mix by the time all was said and done. We love the mix! It is a very nice blend of materials ready to plant right out of the bag. Will keep you posted on how the garden does through the season. First attempt at big raised bed garden here. But again, love the bed mix!!

    Reply

    • That is great Michael! Your new garden sounds wonderful, please keep in touch and let us know how your garden grows.

      Reply

  5. I think it’s great that you point out that a potting mix is suitable to help the plant grow in pots. My husband just started buying some plants and he was planning to plant them in pots. We were both new to gardening so we weren’t sure as to what were the types of soil we should buy for our new plants. Now, I know that we should be buying potting mixes for our plants for better nutrients and growth.

    Reply

    • Hi Alicia, we are glad this has helped you out! Let us know if you have any questions.

      Reply

  6. This is our first raised bed garden. Used appropriate soil and plants are looking great. Have more male flowers than female, on squash right now, but anticipate a good yield. Planted 3 weeks ago and used liquid fertilizer for the first time today. We’ve not been gardeners in years past, but, if this garden is successful will have a garden every year.

    Reply

    • Hi Judy! That is wonderful. Squash plants tend to produce more male flowers than female, but you can remove the excess male blooms so the plants can focus on fruit development. Squash blossoms are edible so you can enjoy them on the dinner table too. If you are on Facebook check out this group https://www.facebook.com/groups/organicgardennation/ you can connect with other gardeners to share your successes and ask for advice when needed.

      Reply

  7. Thank you so much for this information on Raise bed gardening. This is my first time using a raise bed for gardening. Now that I know exactly what and how to do it I am really feeling more confident and less stress about doing it. Thank you so much, this is what I need to know.

    Reply

    • Hi Josephine, we’re pleased to hear you enjoyed our blog post and found it helpful. Happy gardening!

      Reply

  8. Hi,

    How to I amend the “RaiSed Bed soil” each year.

    Thank you,

    Yeny

    Reply

    • Hi Yeny, many opt to amend their raised beds in the fall once their season has ended. The best organic matter to amend your soil with is compost, either your own or bagged, but other great options are leaves, wood chips, grass clippings, straw, earthworm castings, and composted animal manure such as chicken, cow, horse, or sheep. Whatever amendment you choose, it’s important to work it into the existing soil. If you are laying it on top then about a 1/2 inch worth, if you are mixing it in then about 1 or 2 inches or 25-30% of your mix. If compaction has occurred you may also want to add more soil to your beds in order to maintain your ideal soil depth. For more information and tips on amending your raised beds check out this article, https://www.kellogggarden.com/blog/soil/amend-soil/. Happy gardening!

      Reply

  9. I used the raised garden soil and almost appears my mix the with regular soil may have been off as the tomatoes and peppers seem to have some curled leaves, yellowing leaves, etc. I think watering is right just wanted to eliminate possible soil issues. Any thoughts?

    Reply

    • Hi Kevin! Your leaves can be turning yellow for quite a few reasons, transplant shock, watering or sun exposure issues, pests or disease, or lack of nutrients. Tomatoes are heavy feeders so they can deplete nutrients from the soil quite quickly. This could be a lack of nitrogen, if the yellowing is starting at the bottom and working its way up that is typically a sign of a nitrogen deficiency. We recommend using an Organic Fish & Kelp Fertilizer https://www.kellogggarden.com/products/kellogg/organic-fertilizers/kellogg-garden-organics-fish-and-kelp-fertilizer/ for a quick nutrient release and slow release Organic Tomato, Vegetable & Herbs Fertilizer as well. https://www.kellogggarden.com/products/kellogg/organic-fertilizers/tomato-vegetable-herb-fertilizer/

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil (2024)

FAQs

Difference Between Potting Mix and Raised Bed Soil? ›

Potting Mix is formulated to feed the soil for plants growing in indoor and outdoor containers, while Raised Bed Soil with its slightly larger particle size, has versatile uses for both larger containers and raised bed gardening.

Can I use potting mix in a raised garden bed? ›

Soil taken from your yard or a garden bed is too dense to use in a pot or raised bed. Instead, for containers, you'll want to use potting mix (also called potting soil), a lightweight and fluffy alternative. For raised beds, you'll want to use a blend of potting mix and garden soil.

Is raised bed soil better than potting soil? ›

Potting mix is too light to be raised in beds, while garden soil is too heavy. Raised bed soil possesses amazing drainage properties that help establish a favorable environment for your plants.

What soil should I use for raised beds? ›

However, it's generally accepted that the optimum raised bed soil mix includes a blend of topsoil, compost and organic matter.

What is the difference between potting mix and garden soil? ›

Potting mix is meant to stand alone, as opposed to being mixed in with existing soils. It is a self-contained product designed to provide potted plants with everything they need to grow and thrive. Garden soil is meant to be spread around. Mix garden soil in with your native dirt to improve it.

How to fill raised beds cheaply? ›

To start, lay down sheets of cardboard or newspaper for weed suppression and then fill the raised bed structure halfway up with alternating layers of nitrogen-rich materials (like kitchen scraps and grass clippings) and carbon-rich materials (like wood chips and dried autumn leaves).

What do you fill a raised garden bed with? ›

Next, use yard waste such as grass clippings, sticks, branches, leaves, trimmings, and yard debris to take up some extra space and save you a bit of money on soil. These raised beds of ours are 4 ft x 4 ft and 16 inches high. One large trash can full of yard waste filled it up about halfway.

What not to fill a raised garden bed with? ›

Adding gravel to the bottom of your raised bed for drainage is not necessary and adds another expense. If you don't add junk to the bottom of your bed and use appropriate soil, you should have good drainage. Don't fill your raised bed with ground soil. That defeats the purpose of having a raised bed garden.

How many bags of soil do I need for a 4x8 raised bed? ›

For a 4x8-foot raised bed with a 6” height, using Mel's Mix: about 5 cubic feet each of compost, peat moss, and vermiculite is needed. It usually takes about two to three bags of purchased fertile mix (1.5 cubic feet each) to cover the bed surface to a depth of 2 inches.

Do I need to add anything to raised bed soil? ›

1) Add Compost to Your Garden Beds

My number one go to choice always. Compost has the important nutrients plants need, great soil building properties, microorganisms to improve and mediate undesirable soil, and you make it for free.

How deep should a raised bed be to grow tomatoes? ›

Tomatoes should ideally be grown in a raised bed that's at least 15 to 18 inches deep. Many of my clients in Houston are successfully growing tomatoes in 12-inch deep raised garden beds, but their plants tend to be a little stunted compared to plants in deeper beds.

What is the best soil mix for tomatoes in raised beds? ›

The soil is the key ingredient to a successful raised vegetable bed. Get enough light topsoil or raised bed soil to fill the estimated depth of the raised bed. Since tomatoes are heavy feeders and prefer a rich, organic soil, mix in two- to three-inch layers of compost or cow manure to the top one-third of the topsoil.

What is the best base for a raised bed? ›

Newspaper or Cardboard

Even simple, cheap materials can block weed growth from below your garden beds. You can simply lay them on the ground before setting your garden beds on top of them.

Is raised bed soil the same as potting soil? ›

Potting Mix is formulated to feed the soil for plants growing in indoor and outdoor containers, while Raised Bed Soil with its slightly larger particle size, has versatile uses for both larger containers and raised bed gardening.

Is it OK to use garden soil as potting soil? ›

Can You Use Garden Soil as a Substitute for Potting Soil or Vice-versa? Yes, you could use either garden soil or potting soil to grow outdoor plants. However, potting soil is a better choice as a growing medium as it's specifically created to support plant growth.

Do plants grow better in potting mix or soil? ›

Potting Mix vs Potting Soil: Which One Should You Use? Potting soil's composition makes it suitable for outdoor plants. On the other hand, a soilless potting mix is a better choice for potted plants or a container garden because it: Offers a good balance of moisture retention and water drainage for potted plants.

Why can't you use potting soil in the garden? ›

Use potting soil for growing plants in containers or starting seeds, but not for flower beds or raised beds. It's too expensive for large areas and lacks nutrients to feed plants season after season.

What do you line a raised planter box with? ›

As a final reminder, avoid lining your garden beds with plastic. Doing so prevents drainage and could drown your plants' roots with too much water. If you have a weed and pest problem, consider installing a combination of metal mesh and fabric or hardware cloth and cardboard to address both issues simultaneously.

Can you use potting soil in a vegetable garden? ›

Use Premium Potting Soil

To grow a successful container vegetable garden, start with great soil - not soil from your yard, but what's known as a potting mix. These mixes, like Miracle-Gro® Potting Mix, contain the right blend of materials to create an ideal growing environment for roots inside a pot.

Can I use potting mix instead of soil? ›

Potting Mix vs Potting Soil: Which One Should You Use? Potting soil's composition makes it suitable for outdoor plants. On the other hand, a soilless potting mix is a better choice for potted plants or a container garden because it: Offers a good balance of moisture retention and water drainage for potted plants.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 5726

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.