The Best And Worst Breads For Egg Salad Sandwiches - Chowhound (2024)

Chas53/Getty Images

A simple egg salad sandwich is a top-notch choice on those lazy days when you're not up for cooking a big meal. With all the ingredients on hand, you can whip one up in less than 10 minutes. Just mix chopped hard-boiled eggs with a creamy, flavorful dressing made from mayo, Dijon mustard, vinegar, herbs, and maybe some cottage cheese for an extra protein-rich egg salad, then slap it between two slices of bread ... and voila! It's no wonder this sandwich is a go-to comfort food for many.

Advertisem*nt

But here's the deal: Not all egg salad sandwiches are created equal. The secret? It's all about the bread. Some people prefer soft, fluffy bread that lets the egg salad shine, while others like a bit of crunch or bread that adds its own flavor to the mix. So, before you assemble your sandwich, consider the flavor and texture you're craving and choose your bread wisely from the bakery.

Chas53/Getty Images

If you want a sandwich that doesn't make a mess when you eat it, classic white bread or soft whole-grain is your best bet. The soft texture acts like a cozy pillow for the egg salad filling, ensuring it stays put when you take a bite so that there are no eggy spills on your lap! While both are great choices, many lean toward whole-grain since it's less processed, and itsflavor pairs beautifully with egg salad. For an extra indulgent twist, you can also try milk bread or brioche. They'll amp up the richness, although with brioche, it's more like an egg salad roll than a sandwich.

Advertisem*nt

In the mood for some experimenting today? Give potato bread or croissants a shot. Potato bread's fluffy, slightly sweet taste complements the egg salad quite nicely. And as for the croissant, well, the crumbly texture offers a whole new tasting experience that can be a fun and tasty departure from the usual egg salad sandwich— especially handy when you've got a lone, purposeless croissant hanging out in the fridge!

Fudio/Getty Images

Look, when it comes to making your egg salad sandwich, there's no such thing as the "worst" bread. It all boils down to what you enjoy. If a particular bread tickles your taste buds when paired with egg salad, go for it!

Advertisem*nt

That said, some bread types might appeal more to people who want a bit of contrast in their sandwich experience. Loaves with crunchy, tough textures like multigrain or rye can be a bit challenging to bite through, so the filling can sometimes spill out and make a mess. But for some, who love the taste of multigrain and rye's unique earthy flavors juxtaposed against egg salad, these breads add a satisfying crunch and taste. If you don't crave that contrast and are more about savoring the egg salad filling, intensely flavored breads like a seeded bagel orfresh-baked sourdough bread probably aren't very good picks. Their strong flavors can interact with the delicate taste of the salad, leading to a less satiating bite.

Advertisem*nt

But hey, there's no wrong choice here. The key is to pick a bread that suits your preferences. Whether you prefer a plain loaf for balance, flavored bread for extra tastiness, or a heavily textured one for a satisfying crunch, go with whatever makes you happy!