The Discontinued Costco Cake We're Desperate To Have Back (2024)

Stacie Adams

·3 min read

Among the many perks of being a Costcomember, the store's impressive bakery selection ranks pretty high. This warehouse retail chain is known for its assortment of substantially-sized baked goods, including the massive all-American chocolate cakethat captivated the hearts and bellies of shoppers. The cake consisted of multiple layers and had enough chocolate to satisfy a small army. As stated in a Reddit thread, this cake "was four layers, weighed 7 pounds, and could put you in a chocolate coma."

Costco has not officially commented on why it chose to eliminate the cake from the bakery lineup, but the timing of its disappearance does provide some clues. Because the cake was discontinued in 2020, it's possible that the pandemic had something to do with its demise. This is similar to the discontinuation of a beloved Costco food court sandwich, which may have been axed in an effort to streamline the food court menu in the wake of the COVID-19 outbreak.

Read more: All The Benefits Of A Costco Membership

The Difference Between The Original Cake And The New Mini Version

Costco created a mini version of its full-sized all-American cake, which was first only available on a seasonal basis. And while Costco's all-American mini cakes have made a triumphant return since their introduction, there is one crucial difference that shoppers should keep in mind. When the Costco Aisles account on Instagram featured the mini cakes, followers expressed delight at the notion of all that chocolatey goodness. However, a commenter clarified that size is not the only difference between these cakes and the original version. The shopper explained, "No fun [mousse] center, just choc cake. Still yummy tho."

While a mousse-filled chocolate cake is the stuff dreams are made of, it's understandable why Costco would opt to not include it in the mini cake recipe. Just consider what a commenter on Reddit said about the discontinued full-size chocolate cake. The person suggested that the complexity and cost involved in making the cake was a possible reason why it's no longer available, and perhaps Costco wanted to make things easier for bakery staff when developing the new smaller version.

There's No Indication The All-American Chocolate Cake Will Return

The Discontinued Costco Cake We're Desperate To Have Back (2)

Thanks to the popularity of the mini chocolate cakes, shoppers holding out hope that Costco will bring back the original all-American chocolate cake are bound to be disappointed. In fact, there's a chance that the mini cakes may only be around for a short while, especially when you consider they were initially introduced as a limited-time item.

Keep in mind that Costco likes to change its inventory to ensure that shoppers have plenty of new items to entice them, and this strategy could also extend to the chain's selection of baked goods. Daily Meal reached out to Costco to get some insight on whether the full-sized cake will return. According to the representative, that information is not readily available. However, they encourage members to submit feedback to Costco corporate regarding products. While there's no guarantee that Costco brass will heed the cries of chocolate-loving shoppers, it's definitely worth the effort for those who still lament the loss of the all-American chocolate cake.

Read the original article on Daily Meal

The Discontinued Costco Cake We're Desperate To Have Back (2024)

FAQs

What happened to Costco cake? ›

It was 2020 when Costco did the unthinkable and suspended the All-American Chocolate Cake. Once a 7-pound, fudge-forward staple for birthdays and barbecues, this masterpiece was discontinued never to return.

Why did Costco discontinue all American chocolate cake? ›

Costco has not officially commented on why it chose to eliminate the cake from the bakery lineup, but the timing of its disappearance does provide some clues. Because the cake was discontinued in 2020, it's possible that the pandemic had something to do with its demise.

What bakery item did Costco bring back? ›

Costco S'mores Cookies Return

Customers raved about their soft texture—but said they become even better when warmed in the microwave or air fryer to really mimic the campfire treat. Now, the S'mores Cookies have been spotted at Costco once again.

What cakes are sold at Costco? ›

Costco sells a few different types of cakes, such as round, sheet, and bar cakes. Once you factor in the various flavors—vanilla, chocolate, carrot, tuxedo, etc. —the variety is never ending. When you think of Costco cakes, it's probably the classic sheet cakes that come to mind.

How much are the Costco mini cakes? ›

These mini cakes are now available at the Costco bakery for $8.99 per pack.

What Costco won't sell anymore? ›

Fish they no longer sell include: Atlantic cod, Atlantic halibut, Chilean sea bass, shark, swordfish (sourced outside of U.S. fisheries) and bluefin tuna. It's a good idea not to buy these endangered fish elsewhere as there are plenty of other kinds that are sustainably farmed.

Where are Costco returned items sold? ›

After they're returned, they're either sent back to the manufacturer or sold to a liquidator that wipes sensitive information. It means any returned TV must be resold as an open box item. Other products have no resale value at all.

What is the new dessert at Costco 2024? ›

Costco has so many new and delicious bakery items in 2024! Some top funds include Cookies -n-cream mini cakes, triple chocolate pie and assorted danishes!

How many slices can you get out of a Costco cake? ›

I know one half sheet cake serves about 48 people.

Does Costco have smaller cakes? ›

Costco is known for its delicious mini cakes. Sure, they may resemble a cute little cupcake, but they are anything but little.

How many people does a Walmart half sheet cake feed? ›

A half-sized sheet pan will make 58 servings and a quarter-sized pan will make 30 servings.

Does Costco make chocolate cake? ›

Enter your delivery ZIP code and browse items available in your delivery area.

Does Costco make pound cake? ›

Costco Just Added This Pound Cake And Fans Say It's 'Criminally Good' (And It's $8!) In addition to all of their unbeatable deals on bulk products and that beloved hot dog combo, one of the things we love most about Costco is the delicious bakery items they're always adding to shelves.

Does Costco sell tiramisu cake? ›

Ferrara's Bakery 8 in. Tiramisu Cake, 2-pack | Costco.

Does Costco make birthday cupcakes? ›

Yes, Costco Bakery Does Make Cupcakes (although theirs are so big they call them mini cakes instead of a cupcake)!

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Annamae Dooley

Last Updated:

Views: 6354

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Annamae Dooley

Birthday: 2001-07-26

Address: 9687 Tambra Meadow, Bradleyhaven, TN 53219

Phone: +9316045904039

Job: Future Coordinator

Hobby: Archery, Couponing, Poi, Kite flying, Knitting, Rappelling, Baseball

Introduction: My name is Annamae Dooley, I am a witty, quaint, lovely, clever, rich, sparkling, powerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.