The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (2024)

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (2)

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (3)

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (4)

larisa Stefanjuk/Shutterstock

ByNatasha Bailey/

Tortillas can be used for anything:pizza crusts, taco shells, casseroles, enchiladas, you name it! The tortilla is a beloved kitchen staple, a flatbread made so simply, that anyone with flour, fat, salt, and water could try it. If you grew up in a home that made them fresh, you know how amazing warm tortillas can taste in the morning with your eggs or as a wrap for lunch. And, maybe your family passed down the techniques they used to make the perfect tortillas. For those who didn't though, the tortilla-making process may be a bit trickier.

One of the biggest complaints beginners make is that their tortillas aren't turning out soft and pliable. Instead, they end up with something difficult to chew and dry. Tortillas seem deceptively simple because of their minimal ingredients, but that means that the methodology becomes all the more important. If you don't make your bread in the right way and use the right tools, you will encounter a few problems.

It's All About Balance And How You Cook Them

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (5)

Fabian Montano Hernandez/Shutterstock

The kind of flour you use is very important. You should use all-purpose, but if need be you could substitute it with bread flour although Simply Homemade Bread warns that kneading will become a bit more complicated. Additionally, all-purpose flour develops more gluten which will make your tortillas more flexible.

Ana Frias, the creator of Muy Delish, goes into more detail about what the dough should feel like in your hands before cooking. She is adamant that the dough should not be tacky. If the bread is sticking to your fingers, add a small amount of flour until it stops sticking. She does warn that going too far in the other direction — adding too much flour during this process — will make the tortillas hard. It's about striking the right balance.

When it comes to the physical cooking process, you must be attentive. If you overcook them, the tortillas will become hard, but you also don't want to undercook the dough. As a safety net, you can place your tortillas in tin foil to let them gently continue to cook after you've removed them (via Baking Needs). So, if you're hesitant as to whether they are done or not, pop them in some tin foil instead of possibly overcooking them. There is no hard rule for how long you should cook your tortilla, it varies from recipe to recipe, but we would highly suggest doing a few "test runs" to see what works best for you.

Recommended

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

The Real Reasons Your Homemade Flour Tortillas Aren't Soft - Tasting Table? ›

If you overcook them, the tortillas will become hard, but you also don't want to undercook the dough. As a safety net, you can place your tortillas in tin foil to let them gently continue to cook after you've removed them (via Baking Needs).

Why are my homemade tortillas not soft? ›

Adding too much flour to knead or to roll out the tortillas will also create hard and dry tortillas. Do not overcook. It will dry out the tortillas and create tough tortillas. Thinner tortillas require less time to cook than thicker tortillas.

How to make flour tortilla taste better? ›

10 Tips For Making Store-Bought Tortillas Taste Restaurant...
  1. Char them. ...
  2. Toast them in the oven. ...
  3. Fry them. ...
  4. Add water before warming. ...
  5. Steam them to keep them moist. ...
  6. Heat flour tortillas in butter. ...
  7. If you must use a microwave, wrap tortillas in plastic or a damp towel. ...
  8. Heat in large batches in the oven.
Jul 10, 2023

Does too much baking powder make tortillas hard? ›

However, the version I tested that had more baking powder resulted in a thicker, doughy tortilla that wasn't as pliable and was harder to roll when making a burrito or wrap. I also found that they got harder when stored compared to this recipe and the version that did not have baking powder at all.

Why are my flour tortillas chewy? ›

Baking powder creates the bready, chewy texture. Cooking the tortillas on a very hot skillet results in maximum tenderness.

How to warm flour tortillas and keep them soft? ›

Preheat your oven to 300 degrees. Wrap your tortillas in aluminum foil and place in the oven for 10-15 minutes until fully heated through. We find that stacks of 6-8 tortillas or fewer works best. If you have more tortillas than this, you can do multiple packs at the same time.

Can you let tortilla dough rest overnight? ›

However, it is best to think of that 15-minute period as a minimum resting time. Some tortilla makers cover their dough and rest it overnight in the fridge, making it even easier to work with.

How do you harden flour tortillas? ›

Turn soft tortillas into hard taco shells

Take an empty microwave-safe glass cup and fold a soft tortilla in half and place in the microwave for 30 seconds. This creates a hard taco shell, perfect for filling with skirt steak, crispy fish or whatever else your taco-loving heart desires.

What does baking soda do in flour tortillas? ›

Sodium Bicarbonate:

During tortilla production, it is necessary to have some of the leavening occur early in the process, enabling uniform distribution of gas cells. The sodium bicarbonate should then release carbon dioxide just prior to the press and oven.

How do Mexican restaurants heat flour tortillas? ›

The secret is in the steam. Mexican restaurants steam hundreds of tortillas at a time in large ovens or special steamers.

Why do my flour tortillas come out crunchy? ›

If your tortillas are not soft there can be several reasons: You did not use all purpose flour. You did not use a cast iron pan. Your pan was not hot enough.

How to make tortillas pliable? ›

Wrap a stack of tortillas in damp paper towels or a damp kitchen towel, then wrap in plastic wrap or place in a microwave-safe resealable plastic bag (keep the bag open to vent). Microwave until warm and flexible, about 1 minute.

Do tortilla presses work for flour tortillas? ›

Despite common belief, tortilla presses are great for flour tortillas. Not only do tortilla presses speed up the process, but they also eliminate the mess of flour that is usually associated with rolling tortillas out with a rolling pin.

Why do my homemade flour tortillas break? ›

A common problem with homemade tortillas is cracked and jagged edges, a surefire sign that the dough needs more water. You can prevent cracked tortillas by pressing a test tortilla before you roll the rest of the dough into balls.

Why are my tortillas hard after cooking? ›

If you overcook them, the tortillas will become hard, but you also don't want to undercook the dough. As a safety net, you can place your tortillas in tin foil to let them gently continue to cook after you've removed them (via Baking Needs).

How do you keep tortillas from getting mushy? ›

Rebecca, try this: Heat one cup vegetable oil in a medium skillet over medium-high heat until the oil bubbles immediately when you stick the edge of a tortilla onto the surface. Working one at a time, fry a tortilla, turning once, until it just starts to brown and crisp (about 10 seconds per side).

Why are my homemade tortillas sticky? ›

Sounds like the dough is too wet. You should also try leaving them a smidge thicker. I find that when I get my tortillas too thin, they stick pretty badly.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Laurine Ryan

Last Updated:

Views: 6722

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Laurine Ryan

Birthday: 1994-12-23

Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

Phone: +2366831109631

Job: Sales Producer

Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.